Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie… Oh My!

Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie

There’s nothing like a good chocolate chip cookie… unless of course, if it’s super-sized and more than an inch thick. So when I found this recipe from my aunt’s Nestle Classic Recipes Cookbook a while back, I knew it was a must-make. Serve it warm, with ice cream, with syrup… and with caution… because you’ll definitely want another slice.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie

Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie… oh my!

Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie
1 unbaked 9-inch (4-cup volume) deep-dish pie shell*
2 large eggs
1/2 cup all-purpose flour
1/2 cup granulated sugar
1/2 cup packed brown sugar
3/4 cup (1 1/2 sticks) butter, softened
1 cup (6 ounces) semi-sweet chocolate morsels
1 cup chopped pecans
Serve with ice cream (optional)

  • Preheat oven 325 degrees F.
  • Beat eggs in large mixer bowl on high until foamy.
  • Beat in flour, granulated sugar and brown sugar. Beat in butter.
  • Stir in morsels and nuts and spoon into pie shell.
  • Bake for 55-60 minutes. Cool on wire rack. Serve warm.

Recipe from Nestle Classic Recipes, 2003
* If using frozen pie shell, use deep dish style and thaw completely. Bake on baking sheet and increase baking time slightly.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie

Leave a Reply to Anonymous Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

260 comments on “Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie… Oh My!”

  1. My husband saw me looking at this entry and drooled.1402.03. 0 If another woman showed up at our door with one of these pies right now, I’m convinced he’d follow her anywhere. Maybe I’ll make it for his birthday.

  2. Heavens to Betsy Ross! Now my computer screen’s all covered in drool (again).

    Too yummy for words. And the “Oh My” is hilarious.

  3. Just for the record, 1402.03. 0 is code for… A small spider scurried across the arrow keys and I tried to scoop it up. (from my earlier post)

  4. Oh my is right!! Will you marry me with that pie?? That looks to die for!

  5. I gain weight just looking at your photos. This one made me 5 lbs heavier in just 30 seconds. I need a Bakerella diet but can’t control myself.

  6. Oh my goodness! Your photos make me so hungry!

  7. That looks so chocolaty and good!

  8. Heaven exists in the middle of a chocolate cookie pie… :)

  9. *Yummi*!!!! or like I sa in swedish *mums*!
    I have to try it som day!

    /Silver

    this is my cake homepage.. you are welcome to take a look if you like. :)

    http://cakesbysilver.bloggagratis.se/

  10. Bless you. I’ve been looking for a recipe just like this lately and had been striking out. This looks AMAZING!

  11. That looks AMAZING!! Have you had (or seen) the chocolate chip cookie lava cake from Red Lobster? Its so insanely good!! I’ll have to try this and see if it will be a make it at home version.
    -Kate

  12. OH. MY. LORD.
    That looks like heaven on a plate.
    Yum.

  13. That looks delicious!!

  14. I think I’m drooling!!!

  15. This looks HEAVENLY. What do you think about using a graham cracker crust instead?

  16. This looks AMAZING!! What do you think about using a graham cracker crust instead?

  17. You are simply amazing.
    I just brought my receptionist in to show her the pics on your blog!!
    That pie looks amazing and I will definately be making it someday.
    I like recipes that don’t have a 100 ingredients! Not that there are any with that many, you know what I mean..hehe

  18. Wow, that looks sinfully good. After a baking disaster yesterday I think I may redeem myself with an attempt at this yummy goodness!

  19. I just licked my screen. Looks yummy!

  20. This is so decadent! It looks delish.

  21. oh, i have that book and I have made that pie a few times! we love it!

  22. Wow, look so delicious! My hubby would just love this. Gotta try it this weekend! :)

  23. Oh my DAYS. I am in love with you. No, I mean, actually. Please marry me, with greatest haste.

  24. You are killing me with all this yummy goodness! I want to take a bath in that pie!

  25. It’s soooo wrong but so right! lol! It looks so tasty!

  26. I’m going to have to try this one, and convince my husband that he likes pie… at least this one. *drool*

  27. Sometimes those classic recipes are just the best, aren’t they??

    Great pics- I love the curly chocolate chip picture :)

  28. I have seen this recipe and wondered if it would be a good one to try!! Thanks for checkin it out…can’t wait to make one!! looks yummy!!
    I loved your cupcake pops….such a cute and yummy idea!

  29. I could happily drown in that cake.

  30. tina – cute!

    Robyn – Mine too – every time I see this pic.

    tina – oooh – I was wondering.

    bakingblonde – you’re funny!

    MMW – awe thanks!

    the southern hostess – at least they can’t really make you gain weight.

    Kevin – Yep!

    Mrs. Cupcake – And on the top, too!

    Silver – it’s pretty good and thanks for the link!

    Mrs. Ca – no problem.

    Brent – I haven’t tried that, but if it’s chocolate, I’m sure it’s good.

    Scary Mommy – thanks

    Amber – it was.

    Julia – me too!

    Melissa – I think that sounds great!

    JillyRae – I totally agree.

    Azzy – treat yourself.

    meggan – very funny!

    Patricia Scarpin – thanks! It was really good. But I’m a sucker for chocolate.

    Philigry – I need to get the book for myself.

    candyce – Good luck.

    Indigo – Wow… but I think I’m already engaged to bakingblonde from above. One pie and two marriage proposals. I guess I should bake this again.

    Angela – You guys are funny!

    Kerry – I know. Why do these things have to be bad for us.

    Hol&J – Oh, he’ll like this one.

    RecipeGirl – Yeah, I think you’re right and thanks for noticing the little chip. It took a while to get a good pic of it.

    Tara – I think it’s worth it and thanks on the pops!

    Susan from Food Blogga – too cute – glad you like it.

  31. I first saw this recipe about 20 yrs ago and just recently went looking for it to no avail…thanks for posting it! We have a church get together in a week…I think I will bring it along!

  32. Looks decadent and I bet it tasted just as :)

  33. OK, I think you finally found the cure for PMS for sure!!!!

  34. Oh, my is right…I’ve just found your blog…it is FABULOUS!!! I can’t wait until I have time to sit down and devour the whole thing! :)

    And, Martha!!! Wow! THAT is the coolest!

  35. Oh My GOOD GRAVY!! That looks delicious. I posted last week and made the oreo pops for a cake walk at school. They were such a hit, I just finished making more for my daughter’s first communion party on Sunday. I dipped them in white almond bark with pink drizzles. They will be the most adorable party favors. THANKS!!!

  36. This is my favorite cookie recipe, I can’t wait to try it in a big fat chocolatey pie, and the ice cream will just topp it off. Try making as just cookis and make ice cream sandwiches! It is quite delightful, our families favorite! I love the site too, thanks for the ideas!

  37. That looks delicious! Probably easier than fighting with 4 hot cookie sheets and two little girls trying to touch them all as I pull them out!

  38. Do you think a graham cracker crust would work for this recipe?

    It looks good but I am not a pie crust fan. Just thought I’d throw that out there…

  39. OH MY!! Is right!!! This looks marvelous!!!

  40. Oh my, did you hear the thud? I just fell out of my seat. My face instantly gravitated toward my computer screen… and BOOM!

    I must have a piece of that! Thanks for sharing the recipe. It’s a must for this weekend:)

  41. I love your blog, Bakerella! Saw your spot on Martha. Good for you!

    This pie looks fabulous…tasty and well-captured in your photos.

  42. This is so funny…my mom just made this – she calls it Tollhouse Pie! I had just checked my e-mail and found the recipe and then checked your blog to see it on the screen! Must be the season for it! This stuff is amazing. She puts it in a chocolate pie crust for even more amazingness. :-)

  43. Beth – Oh good. Glad to help.

    Tartelette – yes sireee!

    Kendalls Mom 3 – No doubt!

    Bridget – Thanks!

    Trista – they sound pretty!

    Kacey & Chris – I like that idea, too!

    Nicole – Yeah, this way, you just have to make sure the slices are all the same size.

    Becky – I think it sounds good.

    Otter – thanks

    Melissa Lewis-Off The Wall – so funny. Who knew desserts could be so dangerous.

    Beth – thanks. glad you like the pics, too.

    JessK – I like the way your mom thinks!

  44. Oh good grief. I have to make this now!

  45. The only thing that is terrible about this blog, is the fact that my coworkers and I just started a 3 week long pact of no treats. Unless it’s homemade on someone’s birthday.

    I really hope someone makes it for someones birthday because it’s beautiful. I think that is strongly attributed to your beautiful photos.

  46. OMG i must go make this RIGHT NOW!!!!!!!

    btw, i love your blog! everything is so adorable!

  47. I so wanted this recipe to be good, it’s my husband’s two favorite things mixed together. But the pie has been in the over now for 90 minutes and the top is brown, but the insides are still liquid. So sad :(

  48. Suzyhomemaker – I know. It has that effect.

    Patti – thanks a bunch.

    dessertobsessed – like I said, it has that effect…

    regan – that is sad. And your husband probably is too. I’m sorry it’s not working for you. I’ve made it several times without any trouble. Maybe it will still be ok even after the extended oven time.

  49. This looked so yummy that we just had to make it…. just got finished eating it… and it was to die for!

  50. This looks so amazing! Congratulations on all your success.

  51. Sierra – Oh good! I’m glad you liked it.

    artisansweets – thank you!

  52. This dessert looks absolutely to die for! I love your blog, and am in love with those cake pops! Congrats on getting on the Martha show!!!

  53. I made this on Sunday! It was so darn easy and quick and boy did it taste Heavenly! The fam couldn’t get enough of it. Needless to say it didn’t last very long. Thank you for sharing this lovely recipe!

  54. I had to try this recipe and it is SO good! My husband absolutely loved it and would have eaten the whole thing.

  55. Pure Evil….must. resist. the. pie.

  56. oh my goodness this looks good. I am definitely going to try this recipe with some creamy vanilla ice cream..thanks for the inspiration, to die for!

  57. Steph – thanks a bunch!

    Kairlotta – I’m glad you loved it. It is pretty easy.

    Anonymous – Yay! I’m glad it was yummy.

    Sarah – just give in.

    scoopalicious – you’ll love it.

  58. I just made this tonight. HOLY HALLELUJAH!!! It was incredible! I think my husband fell in love with me all over again.

    I had some pastry left from the trimmings when I lined my pie shell, so I made a little mini pie in a 4-oz. ramekin, scooping a little bit of the cookie filling in. It baked for about 45 minutes along with the pie and it was great!

  59. stephanie – I’m glad to hear they turned out so good in the small size. I wanted to make some minis from this recipe, but I haven’t tried yet. Thanks for the info.

  60. Okay, you have so many (well deserved!) comments already, but I have to say that looks SO amazing! I may have found my birthday cake here. Chocolate chip cookies are my favorite thing next to cake, and I think I’ve just found a little bit of both!

  61. colette – I agree. I love a good choc chip cookie anyday.

  62. I have mine cooling right now to take to my In-Laws tonight for dessert. I am crossing my fingers that it looks half as yummy as yours does!

  63. Oh my is right. I’m drooling…

  64. Anonymous – I hope it did too!

    Alysia – yep! it’s yummy.

  65. this is my family’s favorite thanksgiving pie. i made it this year for my inlaw side’s festivities and it was a hit-everyone chose it over the classics.

  66. Seriously I think I could eat that whole pie,,,Oh My..that looks so so so yummy,,,I have to try this one…thanks for leaving the recipe looks so good..Lisa

  67. Cannot wait to make for my grandson’s 15th birthday. Will I be the coolest grandmother or not!!!

    JanisLU

  68. {lizzythebotanist} – I know why. It’s so yummy!

    Pumpkin Pink Cottage – I almost ate the whole thing myself. Over a few days of course.

    Anonymous – I think you will!

  69. Thank you for posting this recipe, along with those amazing pictures (they truly made my mouth water)! My husband is a HUGE chocolate chip cookie fan so I made this for him last night. Not only was it super simple to make but it was over the top yummy! Although my pants aren’t fitting quite the same today, it was totally worth it. This recipe is a definite keeper!

  70. Oh my! This looks and sounds so so delicious. I’ve never even imagined anything so awesome.

  71. cyndi & lee and eatme_delicious – You guys are making me want another one. I’ll be in the kitchen.

  72. This sounds awesome!

  73. I made this tonight and took it to dinner at my grandparents’. Lo and behold, it was a hit! I have now forwarded them the link to this post, so your ratings with the over-70 demographic just jumped. You’re welcome ;)

  74. Oh it is tamy!

    Thanks Lyndsee and hi Lyndsee’s Grandparents!

  75. Thank you, thank you, thank you, for posting this my kids loved it!

  76. Oh man, when I saw this I had to make it, and I told my mom I was going to. She told me she’d tried to make it years before, but it just turned out like liquid in the center. The same happened to me. :-\ I put it back in for another 45 minutes, and it’s still fairly wet in the center (but the tops and such are now hard and semi-burnt). No idea what we both (and another commenter, I saw) did wrong!

  77. Marla – you’re welcome! you’re welcome! you’re welcome!

    nicole – I don’t know either unless your eggs were not beaten enough “until foamy” or maybe your butter was too soft. Did you let it get to room temp or too much, like melted butter? Also did you preheat the oven enough?

  78. Thanks for posting the recipe. I made one for my co-workers birthday yesterday and it looked so delicious, I had to make another for my husband. I love that it only has like, 6 ingredients as well!

  79. Yeah, I’m all for minimal ingredients and maximum payoff!

  80. I have been drooling over this pie since you posted it. I just made two (one for my family and the other for a new neighbor) and they are in the oven now. I can’t wait to dig in!

    P.S. I think you are so talented. I love your site and get excited when you’ve posted something new. Thanks for keeping it up for us to enjoy! :)

  81. YUM! Best thing I’ve ever put in my mouth! :)

  82. Oh my is right! I will be trying this for sure!

  83. jamie b- I’m so glad it was a hit. It’s really good isn’t it.

    emily (adorn) – you’ll be happy!

  84. I made this last week and it was to die for. I will definitely be making it again. My family loved it.

  85. Eva – glad you enjoyed it. It’s on my fave list too!

  86. I made this to take to our Father’s Day BBQ. It didn’t turn out quite like yours. All the chis sunk to the bottom and it was as dense as I’d have liked, but it was still really good and super easy. Thank you!

  87. Melanie – I’m glad it tasted good though.

  88. I’m going to try this one definitely. It looks yummilicious :)

  89. Should I use salted butter, or unsalted? The salt in butter issue has led to my baking downfall before, so I want to make sure to do this correctly.

  90. mistress of the dark – enjoy

    erin – the recipe didn’t specify. I’m pretty sure I used salted though. Make sure your eggs are beaten until foamy.

  91. wah! this looks so good on your blog, but i just tried it and it didn’t work..

    it was completely liquid throughout the entire pie. :tears: it still tasted good, but it was soupy –

    how long do you beat your eggs for?

    i guess my butter was too soft, because i did melt it in the microwave until softened, but it was pretty runny when i dumped it in.

    any ideas?

  92. Cammi – sounds like your butter was too soft and I did beat my eggs for a while. The batter was actually pretty thick when I poured it in the pie shell. Next time let it set out on the counter to get to room temp. That way you won’t accidentally get it too soft.

  93. yay! thank you, i am off to try it again right now :)

    the butter is super soft, all by itself on the counter…

    I adore your website, you are wonderful!

  94. i made this pie using my own home made crust and it was gone before 10 am on the day I brought it to work!! Success!

  95. cammie – good luck!

    Anonymous – Yay! Glad they loved it.

  96. In the oven now… 9 minutes to go and looking/smelling YUM-O… already have the ice cream on standby. Many more of your treats to be made soon! LOVE the blog! Happy baking!

  97. This is awesome, thanks for the recipe! I made this in little individual pie tins (mini chicken pot pie size) and was perfect to take over when I was bringing dinner to another family! And so easy!

  98. Oh my is right! I know I’m going to have to make this soon!

  99. To all those who had trouble with the liquid pie issue:
    when i took mine out to test it after an hour, it was still really watery but i couldn’t wait so i took it out and let it cool and after a while it solidified and it was fabu! i suspect the butter was the culprit for me too so next time i make this (and there WILL be a next time!) i may skimp on the butter a tad and make sure i let it cool overnight so it can really set. i had a liquidy piece last night and a hard piece this morning and they were both devilishly delicious…

  100. Jen – Hope you enjoyed it.

    Sharee Forman – cool. I was going to do that, so I’m glad to know it works.

    PheMom – you’ll love it.

    Elizabeth Shapiro – so glad you like it. How soft was your butter when you added it? I wonder if it melted too much.

Leave a Comment »