Chocolate or Vanilla?

Chocolate or Vanilla

Which would you choose?

Would it matter if I wasn’t talking about cupcakes that you eat?

What if it was something that you wear?

Johnny Cupcakes

Hmmm? I wonder what’s in there.

Well, I ordered something a few weeks ago from Johnny Cupcakes. They sell tons of cool shirts with their cupcake logo in all kinds of designs.

And this one is really cute. Like super cute. At least I think so.

As soon as I saw it, I had to place an order online.

Frosting Cans

And then these arrived a few days later. Magic.

They’re frosting label paint cans. But instead of paint or even frosting, they are filled with a fluffy t-shirt in chocolate or vanilla.

I’m a sucker for cute packaging and these are over the top.


The shirts are designed to look like the packaging label and would be adorable on.

That’s if you can bring yourself to open the can.

Me? I would have to sit mine on a shelf unopened with the shirt cuddled inside so I could look at it all the time. And especially after I found out these frosting can t-shirts were printed as a limited edition. When I bought them, I didn’t realize they only printed 200 of each. And, yes – they are sold out. All sizes. All colors. Gone. They had strawberry too, but those were scooped up first.

The good news is I have two of them. I was going to keep one. But since I’m only going to put it on a shelf and look at it. And since I don’t even have a bookshelf to put it on – I thought I would give them both away.

So which would you choose?

Chocolate Frosting Can


Vanilla Frosting Can

Or vanilla?

Frosting Cans

Enter for a chance to win
A Sold Out Limited Edition Johnny Cupcakes Frosting Label T-shirt

(in a super cute can – Size XL)

  • To enter, just let me know which flavor you’d like to have in the comments section here on the website. Easy.
  • Deadline to enter is Wednesday, June 6th at 6 pm ET. SORRY, Time’s Up! Winners announced below.
  • Two winners will be chosen at random and announced on this post at the end of the week.
  • The first person chosen at random will win the shirt and can in the flavor of their choice and the second winner drawn will win the remaining flavor. And if we’re lucky they’ll be both person’s flavorite!

Good Luck!

Giveaway sponsored by me.

We have winners. And a lot of chocolate lovers. No surprise. I wish I had time to create a chart to show the comparison from all of the entries… that would be interesting. But luckily this little giveaway worked out great and for both winners.

The first winner is Charlton (comment #1927). Congrats! You’re getting the chocolate shirt.

And the second winner is Tami (comment # 301) Yay for you too! You’re getting the vanilla shirt.


Leave a Reply to Brianna Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

4,215 comments on “Chocolate or Vanilla?”

  1. Oh my word, those are adorable! In real life it’s chocolate or death, but I’d be happy with either shirt!

  2. vanilla, I like it so much!

  3. Fun packaging. Chocolate please!

  4. Vanilla all the way!!!!!

  5. Chocolate =0)

  6. Both are too cute but I’d go vanilla! :)

  7. im sure i like chocolate!!! …and the chocolate cupcake too!!! :-)

  8. vvvvaaaannnniiiilllllllllllllllllaaaaaaaaaa!!!!

  9. chocolate always, With sea salt

  10. Chocolate :D

  11. I love chocolate cupcakes! Johnny Cupcakes shirts are always so creative! Love the packaging. :D

  12. It would have to be chocolate because chocolate makes you look slimmer, RIGHT?! of course! (Bakerella, you sure you won’t miss them if you give them both out?!?! So generous of you!)

  13. Ooh! So cute! Chocolate!

  14. Chocolate! So dang cute!

  15. Love them both! But admit I am a chocoholic at heart! :)

  16. I could go for either! And those cupcakes look delicious!

  17. Ooh, chocolate. How cute are those!!

  18. Simple, vanilla :)

  19. Chocolate all the way!! For the shirt at least…if it was for the -actual- cupcakes in the pics, I’d go vanilla =p

  20. I want vanilla!! So cute!

  21. Vanilla Ice Ice Baby :)

  22. Chocolate!

  23. Normally I’m a chocolate girl, but that gorgeous blue on the vanilla is too cute to pass up! Vanilla!

  24. Vanilla!! Ooo yummy!! Xx

  25. Vanilla!

  26. Vanilla for sure! These are so cute. :)

  27. Both?????????

  28. chocolate. definitely chocolate.

  29. Vanilla is always my favorite – ice cream, puddings, cheesecake, etc. except for cakes – then it’s chocolate all the way! Thanks.

  30. Definitely Vanilla!! The can is super cute.

  31. Chocolate! I’d be the most stylish girl in the kitchen.

  32. Vanilla!!! :-)

  33. 100% chocolate!!!

  34. Oh, both!! But if I had to choose, I’d prefer the vanilla one <3

  35. Chocolate of course :D

  36. Chocolate. hands down!

  37. Chocolate!

  38. Chocolate :)

  39. Well if this were a real cupcake I’d want a vanilla cupcake with chocolate frosting but since it’s a Tshirt I’m going with Vanilla!!! But I’d be happy with either! :)

  40. Chocolate :). If I have the coice, then always chocolate…

  41. Chocolate! :D

  42. chocolate

  43. Vanilla!!!

  44. Vanilla all the way!

  45. CHOCOLATE of course :)

  46. Chocolate!!!

  47. Chocolate!!! I must go get some now :)

  48. Oooo…vanilla!! how cute!

  49. I’d choose vanilla. Wait, maybe chocolate??? How’s a girl to decide? OK, VANILLA!

  50. Love both, but for cupcakes I say vanilla! <3

  51. Chocolate!

  52. Chocolate hands down! Those are so cute, good luck everyone.

  53. Vanilla!! Keep it simple and classically delicious!

  54. Chocolate! Always chocolate..! So cute!

  55. Love both.but chocolate… My favve

  56. I would loveee the Vanilla! The cupcakes also look fantastic!

  57. Chocolate! :D

  58. Thanks for this gift, I loooove Johnny Cupcakes !
    Vanilla for me !

  59. Chocolate! First choice is always chocolate!

  60. Chocolate all the way baby!

  61. Chocolate! :-)

  62. Chocolate! Although…I want all the cupcakes!

  63. definitely chocolate! yummo!

  64. Chocolate please, so cute

  65. Honestly, vanilla but when it comes right down to it, either will do. :-)

  66. Chocolate girl through and through!! :)

  67. Vanilla :)

  68. I would have to go with Vanilla, it’s so creamy.
    Yum. The tee’s are so cute.

  69. Def Chocolate! Those are supacute!

  70. There is a flavor other than chocolate?

  71. Chocolate! I mean… who can resist?? (Although… if you left me in a room alone with those vanilla temptations they would probably disappear too!)

  72. Chocolate!

  73. Chocolate is yummy

  74. I’d have to say I’m a vanilla kind of person! Chocolate is great and all, don’t get me wrong, but vanilla is super sweet and yummy!

  75. Chocolate… yummmmm

  76. CHOCOLATE! Without a doubt.

  77. Yummy Chocolate!!!

  78. I first said vanilla but for wearing? Chocolate!

  79. chocolate!!

  80. Chocolate!

  81. Vanilla!!

  82. Chocolate for cupcakes!!!!
    (Although I like vanilla when it comes t icecream. ^^)

  83. I can’t say no to chocolate :]!

  84. Oh that’s great. I think I would go with vanilla :)

  85. Chocolate! Cupcakes, candy, fillings, t-shirts all chocolate. Even my furniture is chocolate. I love chocolate.

  86. Chocolate or vanilla…..hmmmm…..Going to go Vanilla on this one!

  87. Chocolate!!!

  88. Chocolate, please! :o)

  89. Chocolate please!

  90. Chocolate! Yum yum yum!

  91. Chocolate for sure.

  92. Chocolate please! Yum! Thanks for the giveaway!

  93. Chocolate! And the cupcakes look amazingly yummy, too!

  94. Chocolate ALL the way… Hands down!! Good luck. And thank you Bakerella. Hugs

  95. Normally I would choose chocolate, but I LOVE the blue accents on the vanilla… so vanilla it is! :) PS – I love Johnny Cupcakes! I got to check out their store when I was visiting Boston and there is so much cuteness in there, it’s incredible!

  96. Vanilla! Ice ice baby

  97. Vanilla!!

  98. Chocolate!!!

  99. Normally i would pick chocolate, but the vanilla is so cute! I’d be happy either way should i be lucky enough to win :-)

  100. Chocolate pweeeeeez!!

  101. Vanilla all the way!

  102. Chocolate…I am a chocoholic !

  103. I got to meet mom of Johnny Cupcakes in D.C. at a conference last year:)! What a great company! …and I love the chocolate!!

  104. Vanilla all the way!

  105. Oh, chocolate! :D No doubt! :D

  106. I’m going to go with Vanilla I always find chocolate cupcakes a bit on the rich side for me :) How I do love vanilla frosting!

  107. Vanilla!

  108. Chocolate!

  109. Vanilla..

  110. V-A-N-I-L-L-A!! oh lala!!

  111. Wow – too cute and a tough choice! Gotta go with chocolate though! :)

  112. mmmmmmmmmmmmmm definitely chocolate :P—-

  113. I would pick vanilla!

  114. Chocolate, although I wouldn’t mind some Vanilla. Will an edible cupcake be accompanying the paint can/shirt? :0)

  115. VANILLA! YUM!

  116. Vanilla, all the way!!

  117. Chocolate, of course…

  118. Chocolate! Or vanilla!! Love em both!!!

  119. Vanilla! Both are super cute, though!

  120. Chocolate for my girl, vanilla for me.

  121. chocolate over vanilla any day!!!!

  122. chocolate all the way!

  123. Love the chocolate!

  124. Chocolate of course! Wanted to let you know that I love your cake pops and you are so talented. Keep up the awesome work!

  125. Chocolate! These are both so cute!!! I would love to have one!

  126. Chocolate! They’re adorable!!

  127. oohh! definitely vanilla!

  128. Chocolate! Mmmmmmm…

  129. The colors of the vanilla are my favorite. It would totally look great with Jeans.

  130. Right now, I would have to say Vanilla. And cute!

  131. Vanilla : )

  132. Love to have that Vanilla Frosting shirt.. <3

  133. Vanillaaaaaaaaaaa! :)

  134. It’s vanilla for me!

  135. chocolate

  136. Chocolate for the win!

  137. CHOC-O-LATE! ;)

  138. Although I’m a vanilla person when it comes to sweets, I would definitely pick the chocolate tee. I was bummed when I couldn’t get one of these. They sold out fast!

  139. Chocolate, of course. :)


  141. Chocolate!!!

  142. Chocolate! I love Johnny Cupcake shirts!

  143. CHOCOLATE!!

  144. Chocolate!

  145. Vanilla for me! :)

  146. Chocolate!!!

  147. I would definitely choose chocolate. One, because I think the chocolate t-shirt looks cooler, and two, because I would want it to last forever and white is so much harder to get stains out of. Either one, though, would be a fantastic prize to win! Thank you so much for the chance.

    Snoopy :D

  148. They’re both awesome! But if I have to choose, I pick vanilla! Love that blue accent.

  149. really confusing…. I like vanilla cupcake with chocolate frosting and both shirts are cool :)

  150. Chocolate for sure!

  151. Vanilla……but I could go for chocolate too:)

  152. Oh man!! I looooooooooooooove me some chocolate!! BUT I think I like the Vanilla tee better! xoxox

  153. Chocolate, for sure!

  154. Vanilla!!!!! :)

  155. It’s GOTTA be chocolate!

  156. either one would be great! ps. it’s also my birthday so this would be a perfect gift :)

  157. Vanilla!!! even when I LOVE chocolate i have to go with vanilla :)

  158. Chocolate chocolate chocolate!

  159. Chocolate!


  161. Definitely chocolate!!!

  162. Definitely Vanilla!!

  163. Vanilla. :) Those are adorable!

  164. So adorable!! Now I want to eat some chocolate & hope I win the Vanilla ;)

  165. I’m a chocoholic!!! So chocolate it is!!!

  166. Definitely Chocolate! :D

  167. Chocolate definitely!

  168. Either – they are both sweet! Wish the cupcakes were included, though. :o)

  169. Absolutly chocolate!!!!! I´m from Germany, so I have no choise what so ever… Just let me say: I´m a chocolate freak!!! (chocolate for president ;))

  170. for eating, the answer is always vanilla. for this though? chocolate. definitely chocolate.

  171. Vanilla!

  172. Vanilla!
    I love Johnny Cupcakes….I used to have an iPhone case for my old phone :)

  173. It’s really hard to choose, I actually love both flavors. But right now I choose VANILLA

  174. Ooooh, definitely chocolate!

  175. Vanilla is always my favorite!

  176. CHOCOLATE….
    hungry now

  177. It would be a really hard decision… Hmmm… Vanilla!

  178. CHOCOLATE!!!! nom nom…. my favorite. love johnny’s cupcakes

  179. Chocolate. Always chocolate.

  180. Chocolate, of course!

  181. Hard to pick… both of them are great. I think chocolate! :)

  182. Chocolate of course ;)

  183. I would definately take chocolate.

  184. Love all things Chocolate:)

  185. Chocolate!!!!

  186. Vanilla for sure! :) Such cute tees!

  187. Vanilla! Yum!!

  188. Chocolate sooo works for me! But, the vanilla is cute too! :-)

  189. OMG!! I would love the chocolate one! But vanilla would be nice too.
    They r so cute!

  190. chocolate! :)

  191. I would totally go for the chocolate one! But either works for me, too!

  192. Chocolate!!!!! Now I want cupcakes. :)

Leave a Comment »